Quick Answer
Can you get deferred from early decision? Yes, absolutely. Most Early Decision programs defer students to the regular decision round rather than denying them outright. When you're deferred from ED, the binding commitment is released, and you're free to apply to other schools while waiting for the final decision in March. The December-to-March period becomes your strategic window to strengthen your application.
Understanding Early Decision Deferrals: What They Mean and What Happens Next
Every December, I work with families asking, "Can you get deferred from early decision?" The answer is yes, and it happens more often than most people realize. Schools like Penn, Columbia, Northwestern, Duke, and Brown all defer significant numbers of ED applicants each year.
Over my 13 years guiding students through competitive admissions, I've seen hundreds of families navigate ED deferrals successfully. The key is understanding what a deferral means, what happens to your binding commitment, and how to use the next three months strategically.
When your student is deferred from Early Decision, they're not rejected. The admissions committee wants to reconsider their application in the context of the full regular decision pool. This gives your student a second chance, but it also requires a clear action plan from December through March.
What Happens to the Binding Commitment When You're Deferred?
This is the question I hear most frequently after "can you get deferred from early decision?" When a student is deferred from ED, the binding commitment is released. Your student is now free to apply to other colleges and consider multiple options.
If your student is ultimately admitted in the regular decision round from their ED deferral, they'll have until the standard May 1st deadline to make their enrollment decision, just like any other RD admit. They're no longer bound to attend, even though they applied Early Decision originally.
This is crucial to understand because it changes your entire strategy. You're not sitting around waiting for one school anymore. Your student should be actively pursuing other applications, building a balanced college list, and preparing for multiple possible outcomes.
I've worked with students who were deferred from ED at Penn and later admitted to both Penn and several other top schools in the RD round. Because the binding commitment was released, they could compare financial aid packages and make the best choice for their family.
Early Decision Deferral Rates: What the Numbers Tell Us
When families search "can you get deferred from early decision," they often want to know how common this outcome is. The statistics vary significantly by school, but deferrals are far from rare in the ED round.
At schools like Penn and Columbia, historically around 15-20% of ED applicants get deferred each year. Northwestern has deferred roughly 20-25% of their ED pool in recent cycles. Duke typically defers about 15% of ED applicants. These numbers fluctuate based on each school's enrollment management strategy, but the pattern is clear: ED deferrals happen regularly.
What matters more than the overall deferral rate is what happens next. Of students deferred from ED, acceptance rates in the regular round typically range from 5-15%, depending on the school. These aren't great odds, but they're not impossible either. The students who succeed are the ones who use the deferral period strategically.
I've written extensively about college deferral statistics if you want to dive deeper into specific schools and their historical patterns.
The December-to-March Deferral Timeline
Deferred from Early Decision?
Your December to March Action Plan
📅 Mid-December
Receive deferral notification. Take 48 hours to process emotions, then shift to action mode.
📅 Late December
Review deferral letter for specific instructions. Begin drafting Letter of Continued Interest.
✅ Early January
Submit polished LOCI showing unique alignment to the college. Include first semester achievements and grades.
📬 Late Jan - Feb
Send meaningful updates: awards, research progress, leadership developments. Quality over quantity.
🎓 March
Final decisions released. If admitted, celebrate. If denied, strong RD applications are already submitted.
Get expert guidance on your deferral strategy
standoutcollegeprep.com
This timeline applies whether your student was deferred from ED or EA. The strategic approach remains the same: use the December-to-March window to strengthen your application and demonstrate continued interest while simultaneously pursuing other excellent college options.
What to Do Immediately After an ED Deferral
The moment you learn about an ED deferral and realize "can you get deferred from early decision" applies to your situation, your first 72 hours matter enormously.
First, let your student feel disappointed. An ED deferral stings because this was their first choice school. Give yourselves two full days to process the emotions. Then, on day three, shift into strategic mode.
Read the deferral letter carefully. Some schools, like Northwestern, provide specific guidance about what they want to see. Others, like Columbia, are more general. Your response needs to align with what they're asking for.
Here's what I've learned works in this immediate period:
- Don't send anything in the first week. Admissions offices are slammed in mid-December, and your message will get lost.
- Finalize and submit your other college applications immediately. Don't wait. You need a solid backup plan.
- Use the holiday break to draft a thoughtful Letter of Continued Interest, not fire off a hasty email.
- Talk with your student about whether this school is still their absolute top choice. Sometimes deferrals reveal that other schools might be better fits.
- Review their RD applications with fresh eyes. Often, what didn't work in the ED round can inform improvements to regular decision essays.
The question "can you get deferred from early decision" comes from families facing this exact moment. The truth is, ED deferrals create a clear path forward if you follow the timeline strategically and don't put all your eggs in one basket.
Crafting Your Letter of Continued Interest After an ED Deferral
Your LOCI is the centerpiece of your deferral strategy. When families google "can you get deferred from early decision" and find themselves in this position, the Letter of Continued Interest becomes their most powerful tool for staying in contention.
I've reviewed thousands of these letters, and the ones that work follow a specific structure. Let me share what I've seen succeed at the most selective schools.
A strong LOCI accomplishes three things. It reaffirms genuine interest (particularly important if this school is still your first choice despite the deferral), provides meaningful updates, and adds new dimension to your student's application. It doesn't rehash what's already there or beg for admission.
Real LOCI Example That Worked
This student was deferred from Northwestern's Early Decision round and accepted in the regular decision round. Notice how specific the alignment is:
"I have learned enough about Northwestern to know that this is the school in which I see myself flourishing. Currently, I am enrolled in the AP Capstone program and am beginning my own independent research project focusing on conformity within gifted students. With the Baker Program's support of independent undergraduate research, I am hoping to continue to follow my passion for exploration. As a CPS student who has lived in Chicago all my life, staying close to home is one of my priorities while still having access to a rigorous education deeply rooted in breakthrough research."
The timing of your LOCI matters as much as the content. I recommend submitting it in early January, after the holiday rush but before regular decision applications flood the office. This positions your student's updates in front of readers when they're building their admitted class.
For detailed guidance on writing effective letters, check out my comprehensive guide on how to write a LOCI and review common LOCI mistakes that kill your chances.
Meaningful Updates: What to Share After an ED Deferral
After your initial LOCI goes out in January, you might wonder what else to communicate. Understanding "can you get deferred from early decision" includes knowing when and what to update.
I tell families to send updates only when they're truly meaningful. Winning a major award, publishing research, earning a significant leadership position, or achieving notable academic recognition all qualify. Getting another A in calculus does not.
Here's my test: Would this update add a new dimension to your student's application, or does it simply reinforce what's already there? If it's genuinely new and impressive, send it. If it's more of the same, hold off.
Timing matters here too. Space your updates at least three weeks apart, and send nothing after late February unless it's truly extraordinary. Admissions committees are making final decisions by early March, and late updates can feel desperate rather than impressive.
The updates that have worked best for my deferred ED students include:
- National or state-level academic awards like National Merit Finalist, Regeneron Science Talent Search semifinalist, or state-level debate championships
- Significant research developments, especially publications in academic journals or presentations at recognized conferences
- Meaningful leadership achievements, like founding a new organization or expanding an existing club's impact significantly
- First semester senior grades, but only if they show marked improvement or maintain a perfect record in the most rigorous courses available
- Major creative accomplishments, like leading roles in competitive theater productions or acceptance into juried art exhibitions
For more on what makes an update worthwhile, read my article on senior year updates that strengthen deferred applications.
The Reality Check: Pursuing Other Options While Waiting
When parents ask "can you get deferred from early decision," what they're really asking is whether there's still hope. There is. But hope requires a backup plan.
The biggest mistake I see families make after an ED deferral is becoming so focused on that one school that they neglect their other applications. This is a strategic error. Statistically, most deferred students don't gain admission in the regular round, regardless of whether they were deferred from ED or EA.
Your student needs to fall in love with their other options. Not as backup plans or consolation prizes, but as genuine alternatives they'd be thrilled to attend. This mental shift is hard but essential.
I've worked with students deferred from Penn who ended up at Cornell and loved it. Students deferred from Northwestern who thrived at WashU. Students deferred from Columbia who chose Brown in the end, even after getting admitted to Columbia in the RD round.
Use the deferral as motivation to make your RD applications even stronger. If your student's ED essays felt generic, make the RD essays more specific. If their activities list didn't tell a clear story, reorganize it for RD schools. The deferral is feedback, even if it's not explicit feedback.
Understanding Why Students Get Deferred From Early Decision
Part of answering "can you get deferred from early decision" involves understanding why it happens. Deferrals aren't random, and they're not just polite rejections (though sometimes they can be).
Schools defer ED applicants for several strategic reasons. Sometimes, they genuinely want to see your student in the context of the full applicant pool before making a final decision. Maybe your student is academically strong but the ED pool was exceptionally competitive this year. Maybe they want to see first semester senior grades before committing.
Other times, schools defer students because they're uncertain about yield management. They might admit their absolute top choices in ED, defer the strong-but-not-quite students, and then revisit those deferrals in RD once they know their overall enrollment picture.
Occasionally, deferrals happen because your student is a strong candidate but something in the application raised a question. Maybe their intended major didn't align clearly with their activities. Maybe their essays didn't quite capture what makes them unique. The LOCI is your chance to address these potential gaps.
Real Update Example From a Successful ED Deferral
This student was deferred from an Ivy League ED round and later admitted in regular decision. Notice the balance of achievement and authentic interest:
"Since submitting my application, I have maintained straight A's in the most rigorous courses available at my school. I also recently completed two college-level courses through Coursera, one from Dartmouth on energy and the environment and one from Penn on computational problem solving. These helped deepen my understanding of the interdisciplinary approach I hope to pursue at your university. I've also discovered a student organization I hadn't known about when I applied: the Concrete Canoe Team. This perfectly encapsulates what drew me to your school in the first place, the way students challenge themselves to apply classroom learning creatively while having fun."
What Not to Do During the ED Deferral Period
I've seen well-meaning families sabotage their chances after learning "can you get deferred from early decision" applies to them. Let me save you from these mistakes.
Don't email the admissions office weekly with minor updates. Don't have your college counselor call repeatedly asking about your student's status. Don't send gifts, gimmicks, or anything that could be perceived as trying to buy your way in. These tactics backfire spectacularly.
I once worked with a family who sent elaborate care packages to the admissions office every two weeks in January. They thought it showed dedication. The admissions office found it inappropriate and uncomfortable. The student was ultimately denied, though we'll never know if the packages played a role.
Similarly, don't rewrite your entire Common App essay and send it as an "improved version." The admissions committee already reviewed your application. They don't want to re-read a completely different essay. They want new, additive information that helps them advocate for your student in committee discussions.
Don't assume the deferral means you're definitely getting in during RD. Hope is good. Overconfidence is dangerous. Keep your other applications strong and submit them on time.
When March Arrives: Final Decisions and Next Steps
By late March, you'll have your answer. Families who spent months navigating "can you get deferred from early decision" will finally know whether their ED deferral turned into an acceptance.
If your student is admitted, celebrate genuinely. They've earned a spot in a competitive class, and the extra effort paid off. If they have multiple acceptances to choose from, compare financial aid packages carefully, revisit campuses if possible, and make the choice that genuinely feels right, not just the one that was originally their first choice back in November.
If your student is denied after the deferral, remember that the LOCI and updates weren't wasted effort. They taught your student resilience, strategic thinking, and how to advocate for themselves effectively. These skills matter far beyond college admissions.
And here's what I tell every family: the college admissions process is imperfect and often arbitrary. An ED deferral followed by a denial doesn't mean your student isn't brilliant, capable, or deserving. It means that particular admissions committee, in that particular year, with that particular applicant pool, made a different choice. Your student will thrive wherever they ultimately enroll.
I've watched students denied from their ED deferral school end up at places where they found incredible opportunities, lifelong friends, and genuine happiness. The college that deferred and then denied them becomes a footnote in their story, not the defining chapter.
Final Thoughts on Navigating Early Decision Deferrals
So, can you get deferred from early decision? Absolutely. It's a common outcome at competitive schools, and it creates both challenges and opportunities.
If your student was deferred from ED, you have a clear timeline and strategy to follow. Use December to process emotions and complete other applications. Submit a strong LOCI in early January showing unique alignment to the school. Send meaningful updates through February. And maintain perspective throughout the process.
The binding commitment is released when you're deferred, which means your student can pursue other excellent options without guilt or restriction. This isn't settling. It's being strategic and realistic about the competitive nature of elite college admissions.
I've guided hundreds of families through ED deferrals, and I've seen students move from deferral to acceptance at Penn, Columbia, Northwestern, Duke, and Brown. I've also seen students denied from their ED deferral school who ended up somewhere even better suited to their actual needs and interests.
The deferral period is challenging, but it's also an opportunity. Your student can demonstrate growth, resilience, and genuine interest. They can strengthen their application in ways that weren't possible when they submitted in November. And regardless of the final outcome, they'll enter college with important skills about perseverance and self-advocacy that will serve them for the rest of their lives.
If you need personalized guidance navigating an ED deferral, schedule a strategy meeting to discuss your student's specific situation and create a customized plan for the months ahead.
